2019 marks the 10-year anniversary of Animal Collective’s breakout album Merriweather Post Pavilion, the record that got me into the band, as well as acted as the cement shoes that pulled me down into the nefarious depths of indie rock. Although I no longer consider the band as one of my top favorites at this time, I was a massive fan in high school and college and they definitely had a hand in developing my taste today. Merriweather‘s anniversary got me in the AnCo wave and pulled me back out to sea with these MD boys. I’m kind of sick of listening to so much of them again, so what better way to exorcise an obsession than making an agonizing list? That’s like, my life’s work right there.
Going into making these selections, I made myself a set of questions to ask myself once it was complete. Will I lean towards songs lead by Panda Bear or Avey Tare? Will I be pulling all the hits? Will I find any deep cuts that I adore? Will any of their early material make the cut? Will any of their recent material make the cut? Would my current favorite album of theirs, Strawberry Jam, hold up after being picked apart? Is “My Girls” gonna be my favorite song? In short, am I going to be incredibly predictable?
Check out my top 10 favorite Animal Collective songs below, complete with Warm Visions description flair, along with an analysis of my picks below that.
- “Fireworks” [Strawberry Jam]
Leisurely riding your bike home on a warm Friday evening with the sun in your eyes at the start of the commute and the sun dramatically setting at the end of it.
- “Bleed” [Fall Be Kind EP]
Every night you have a dream of being buried alive, which eventually leads you to find solace in lying in large patches of dirt above ground & staring at drifting clouds above.
- “My Girls” [Merriweather Post Pavilion]
A living room dance party soundtracked by thunder and heavy rain on the rooftop.
- “For Reverend Green [Strawberry Jam]
A man born without a voice box jury-rigs one together using an old rotary phone and an antenna through his windpipe, eventually gaining the ability to broadcast space station correspondence through his mouth.
- “Daily Routine” [Merriweather Post Pavilion]
Late morning dreams of brainless chores make you feel like blissfully sleeping away the day is synonymous with being productive.
- “The Purple Bottle” [Feels]
A backyard party is lit by sparklers, making for not only dynamic lighting but also small pricks of pain when a spark makes contact with skin.
- “Bluish” [Merriweather Post Pavilion]
A hypnotized soul, lost in the undulating riptide of love for another.
- “Cuckoo Cuckoo” [Strawberry Jam]
Giant cracks in the Earth’s surface caused by an earthquake emit at once both chaotic and harmonious frequencies across the planet.
- “Safer” [Peacebone EP]
A nonsensical slideshow of memories and sensations flash before your eyes in the throes of entering the afterlife.
- “Prospect Hummer” [Prospect Hummer EP]
A chorus of frogs back up a wispy grasshopper soprano in a club secluded by tall reeds.






